Unblocking results: using aid to address governance constraints in public service delivery

Unblocking results: using aid to address governance contraints in public service delivery
Heidi Tavakoli, Rebecca Simson and Helen Tilley with David Booth
May 2013
This publication is an output of the following project: Budget Strengthening Initiative
Overview

Governance constraints and weak institutions are a major cause of poor public service delivery in developing countries, yet there is little evidence on whether and how aid can help to release or ameliorate such constraints. Evidence that does exist tends to focus on the impact of particular types of accountability structures (such as user committees and citizen report cards). In contrast, little research has considered the broader implications of governance constraints for the design and delivery of aid programmes.

To address this gap, this study looks at four aid programmes in lower-income countries that appear to have been particularly effective at addressing governance constraints. These include:

The study looks at how these programmes interacted with common governance constraints and what activities and enabling factors appear to have contributed to an effective engagement. It draws on an ODI classification of three common governance constraints: the degree to which sector policies and institutional arrangements are coherent; the strength of top-down performance disciplines and bottom-up accountability mechanisms; and whether there is scope for local problem solving and collective action.

The study looks at the activities that these programmes carried out and finds that six enabling factors appear to have been particularly important for success.

  • Responding to windows of opportunity for reform, be it a political transition or crisis, provides a stronger basis for reform than pure development needs.

  • Focusing on reforms with tangible political payoffs increases the likelihood of strong government ownership.

  • By building on what’s there aid can support the implementation of existing mandates rather than getting trapped in a cycle of perfecting policy and legal frameworks.

  • Moving beyond policy advice by supporting local problem-solving through coaching and mentoring can strengthen government implementation.

  • By acting as facilitators external partners can bear the transaction cost of bringing actors together to solve problems.

  • By being adaptive and responding to lessons learnt external partners can increase their effectiveness.

Language: 
English
ISBN: 
978-1-909464-35-3
Downloads

Unblocking results: using aid to address governance contraints in public service delivery

Unblocking results: using aid to address governance contraints in public service delivery
Unblocking results: using aid to address governance contraints in public service delivery - pdf, 2.29M

Unblocking results (casestudy): addressing pay and attendance of health workers in Sierra Leone

Unblocking results (casestudy): addressing pay and attendance of health workers in Sierra Leone
Unblocking results (casestudy): addressing pay and attendance of health workers in Sierra Leone - pdf, 266.43k

Unblocking results (casestudy): rural water in Tanzania

Unblocking results (casestudy): rural water in Tanzania
Unblocking results (casestudy): rural water in Tanzania - pdf, 328.50k

Unblocking results (casestudy): the Africa Governance Initiative in Sierra Leone

Unblocking results (casestudy): the Africa Governance Initiative in Sierra Leone
Unblocking results (casestudy): the Africa Governance Initiative in Sierra Leone - pdf, 268.20k

Unblocking results (casestudy): supporting the development of local government in Uganda

Unblocking results (casestudy): supporting the development of local government in Uganda
Unblocking results (casestudy): supporting the development of local government in Uganda - pdf, 288.55k